Skip to main content

Puttanesca Tomato Salad

  • Prep Time:
  • 10 mins
  • Cook Time:
  • 5 mins
  • Total Time:
  • 0 hour(s)
  • 15 mins

At the height of summer, there is nothing better than a plate of sweet, juicy tomatoes enhanced by the simplest of toppings like mozzarella and basil. And while classic Caprese salad will always have a place in our hearts and at our tables every summer, this season a new tomato salad stole our affections: Puttanesca Tomato Salad. 

Inspired by the popular Neapolitan pasta dish, this salad still has all the traditional components of Pasta Puttanesca—anchovies, garlic, olives and capers—senza (without) the actual spaghetti. Imagine this: thick slices and wedges of heirloom tomatoes nestled with fragrant basil leaves and topped with briny capers, olives and a umami-packed dressing of extra virgin olive oil, Colatura di Alici (think Italian fish sauce), garlic and hot pepper. Is your mouth watering yet?

Recipe, food styling & photography by Asha Loupy

Serves 4-6



In a medium bowl, whisk the extra virgin olive oil, colatura, hot peppers and garlic together until emulsified. Set aside.

To prepare the tomatoes, cut them into varying shapes and sizes; slicing any larger tomatoes into thick slices, medium-sized tomatoes into wedges and cherry tomatoes (if using) in half. 

To assemble the salad, arrange the tomatoes in a single layer on a large serving platter (don't worry about perfection here, this is a rustic salad!). Nestle and tuck the basil leaves among the tomatoes. Sprinkle the olives  and capers over the tomatoes and basil. Spoon the reserved spicy colatura dressing over the whole salad. Finish with a light sprinkling of fleur de sel, if desired.